At a recent conference, I listened as Dr Thomas Wadden presented a portion of what was learned in the decade-long Look Ahead Study.  In examining attrition or drop-outs rates of weight loss patients, one statistic stood out to me.  60% of those patients who drop out of a program attribute unmet expectations as a contributing factor as to why they dropped out.  Simply put, when the numbers a patient sees on the scale are not in line with what they imagined going into their weight loss journey, they are likely to quit.

As I was pondering Dr Wadden’s lecture, I was reminded of a study published in the Annals of Surgery January 1983 by Feurer et al, “Resting Energy Expenditure in Morbid Obesity.” This NIH funded research examined 112 morbidly obese adults prior to gastric bypass surgery.  One of the most significant conclusions of this study was that estimating post-surgical weight loss using predictive formulas is inadequate and that “in view of the inability to generate a valid predictive equation for the morbidly obese, measuring energy expenditure is the only viable alternative.”

So if the intent is to put a patient on a standard VLCD post-operatively (ie,700 Kcals), why would a RMR measurement matter?  The answer ties back to Dr. Wadden’s findings: managing expectations.  If equations don’t give you (the practitioner) adequate predictions of weight loss, then you can’t give your patients a realistic expectation of how to measure what “success” will look like.

Look at these 3 patients from the Feuerer study.  With the same estimated energy expenditure of 1900 Kcals a day, predictive formulas would suggest they should be losing at the same rate post operatively.  But an actual RMR test shows completely different metabolic rates that will lead to drastically different results.

This study shows that even with relatively controlled intake, their metabolic rate will significantly affect the results patients will experience.  An actual RMR test would prepare each of these patients for realistic results, rather than viewing these variations as personal failure or a failure of the program.  This principle applies not only to surgical candidates, but any patient entering a weight loss program.

Disappointment is a difficult emotion to deal with.  Don’t set your patients up to be disappointed with goals based on outdated formulas.  Help them set reasonable, personal expectations with a baseline RMR test and regular re-testing.  Determine your patient’s ability to burn calories with an RMR test, then estimate how much weight they can expect to lose the first month or two on your program.  An RMR measurement is scientific information about each patient that allows you to give them realistic goals you cannot conjure up from any other source.

To read the Feurer study, click here.

2 thoughts on “Resting Metabolic Rate Measurements Produce Realistic Expectations

  1. Rod Hare, R.KIN, (Ontario, Canada) says:

    It is very important to develop realistic goals and intern expectations, which this instrumentation would be helpful for. This information helps illustrate the complexities and just one of the multiple co-factors associated with obesity and why the “weight loss practitioners” should acquire more and specific pertinent information to be utilized in their wight loss programs. Successful or sustained wight loss goes well beyond just eating less and exercising more as we are discovering more and more through the research each day.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Save & Share Cart
Your Shopping Cart will be saved and you'll be given a link. You, or anyone with the link, can use it to retrieve your Cart at any time.
Back Save & Share Cart
Your Shopping Cart will be saved with Product pictures and information, and Cart Totals. Then send it to yourself, or a friend, with a link to retrieve it at any time.
Your cart email sent successfully :)

The European Union’s ePrivacy Directive (often referred to as the ‘cookie law’) and General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) places requirements to provide information about, and gain consent for the use of cookies. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use. To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here